“God intends you to found your marriage on Christ. ‘Wherefore receive ye one another, even as Christ also received you, to the glory of God.’ In a word, live together in the forgiveness of your sins, for without it no human fellowship, least of all a marriage, can survive. Don’t insist on your rights, don't blame each other, don’t judge or condemn each other, don’t find fault with each other, but take one another as you are, and forgive each other every day from the bottom of your hearts.”
— Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Letters and Papers from Prison, p. 42
Marriage is one of the closest, most demanding forms of human fellowship. It forces two people, with all their habits, histories, and hurts, into a shared life. Because of this, marriage becomes a kind of pressure test for whatever we truly believe about love, justice, and “my rights.”
Bonhoeffer’s counsel cuts against much of what we have absorbed from democratic, rights‑oriented cultures: “Don’t insist on your rights.” Not just in public life, but in the most intimate relationship you have.
That sentence can sound dangerous or naïve. Our modern formation says: If I do not insist on my rights, I will be trampled. If I do not protect my liberty, I will lose myself. So how can Bonhoeffer, writing from a Nazi prison, commend this posture not only for public life but especially for marriage?
To begin answering that, we have to think honestly about individual liberty, its goodness, and its limits, and then look at the pattern of Christ Himself.
The Good Gift of Individual Liberty
For those raised in democratic societies, individual liberty feels like the air we breathe. It is the conviction that each person is free to think, speak, act, and live according to conscience, so long as they do not infringe on the rights and freedoms of others.
This is not a small thing. The language of “rights” has protected:
- Human dignity against the abuse of power
- Space for creativity, innovation, and human flourishing
- Freedom to follow conscience in matters like religion and vocation
We know, often painfully, what happens when these freedoms are denied or crushed. When a government, a leader, or even a spouse tramples someone’s basic dignity, the language of rights becomes a necessary protest. “You may not do that. You have crossed a line.”
In that sense, the appeal to rights is often a cry against infringement—against someone else invading what is properly ours as image-bearers of God.
So it would be a mistake to pit Christian selflessness against liberty as if liberty were only a worldly idea. Properly understood, the protection of a person’s God‑given dignity is a moral good.
And yet, Bonhoeffer still says: “Don’t insist on your rights.” How can both be true?
Where Rights Language Starts to Break Down
The problem is not liberty itself, but what happens when the insistence on my rights becomes the primary lens through which I see every relationship.
In public life, an overdeveloped sense of “my rights” can make me hypersensitive, cynical, and endlessly offended. In marriage, it can be lethal.
- “I have a right to be heard.”
- “I have a right to my time, my space, my way.”
- “I have a right not to be spoken to like that.”
Sometimes those sentences name real wrongs. Abuse, manipulation, and contempt are not minor matters to be shrugged off in the name of being “selfless.” Scripture never blesses oppression.
But what Bonhoeffer is after is the posture of the heart: the way we approach the other person as a kind of debtor who must pay us what we are owed. If the instinctive stance in my marriage is, “You owe me”, then forgiveness becomes almost impossible. Every slight is a bill. Every failure is an unpaid invoice. Every conflict becomes an accounting exercise.
It is here that Christ confronts us with a completely different pattern.
Christ’s Pattern: Giving Up His Rights, Guarding Ours
If anyone has a claim to absolute rights, it is Christ.
He is the eternal “I AM,” the Lord of creation, holy, perfect, and just. By rights, His very presence should mean judgment for sinful humanity. His glory should have consumed us. Instead, He laid aside what was His and came down.
Think about the contrast:
- The One who needed nothing subjected Himself to hunger, exhaustion, and loneliness.
- The One worshiped by angels endured mockery, slander, and humiliation.
- The One with authority to judge all allowed Himself to be judged by corrupt human courts.
He gave up the visible exercise of His divine rights in order to redeem those who had despised them. He entered fully into the dirt and pain of this world, not as a tourist but as one who would bear the curse of sin in His own body.
And yet, while He consistently refused to insist on His rights, He never trampled the God‑given dignity of others. He:
- Invited, but did not coerce
- Corrected, but did not manipulate
- Called, but did not control
He never forced faith or repentance. He never bent someone’s will by raw power. He did not threaten His disciples into loyalty. Christ protected human freedom even as He surrendered His own prerogatives for their sake.
So in Christ we see both truths held together:
- A refusal to cling to His own rights.
- A deep reverence for the God‑given dignity and liberty of others.
This is the pattern Bonhoeffer has in view, and it is the pattern that must re-shape how we understand marriage.
From Accounting to Forgiveness: How Christ Reorders a Marriage
Bonhoeffer’s line is not an abstract rule. It is very specific: “God intends you to found your marriage on Christ… live together in the forgiveness of your sins.”
In other words, the foundation of Christian marriage is not compatibility, not shared hobbies, not even romance. It is a shared dependence on Christ’s forgiveness.
When both spouses stand before Christ as forgiven sinners, several things happen.
1. My spouse stops being my project or my opponent.
If I have founded my marriage on Christ, I no longer treat my spouse as someone who must meet all my needs or perform according to my script. I see them as one for whom Christ died, just as dependent on grace as I am.
This makes it much harder to say, “I have a right for you to be exactly what I expect.” Instead, I receive them as they are, trusting the Spirit, not my pressure, to change what must be changed.
2. The scoreboard gets dismantled.
“Don’t insist on your rights” does not mean there is never real wrong. It does mean I refuse to keep a meticulous ledger of every offense.
In practice, that might look like:
- Choosing not to replay the same failure again and again in my mind
- Resisting the instinct to bring past forgiven sins into new arguments
- Confessing my own sin as eagerly as I point out the other’s
A marriage founded on Christ is a marriage where the cross is the central accounting event. Christ has already paid the ultimate debt. So I cannot simultaneously cling to His forgiveness and demand that my spouse pay me back for every wound.
3. Liberty moves from “my shield” to “their shelter.”
Instead of using liberty language to protect my comfort, I begin to use my freedom in Christ to serve the other.
Paul captures this when he says, “You were called to freedom… only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another” (Gal. 5:13).
In marriage that might mean:
- Freely giving time and attention when I’d rather pursue my own agenda
- Laying down preferences in order to bless my spouse
- Being slow to claim “you’re infringing on my rights” and quick to ask, “How can my freedom serve you?”
Here I am not erasing my personhood. I am offering it, patterned after Christ.
Answering the Fear: “What If I Get Crushed?”
At this point a reasonable fear arises: If I stop insisting on my rights, won’t I just get run over?
Christ’s pattern of surrender is not a call to enable abuse or endure sin in silence. Scripture speaks clearly about confronting sin, protecting the vulnerable, and not submitting to evil.
The difference is this: insisting on my rights as my primary tool for self‑protection is not the same as entrusting myself to God and walking in wisdom.
There are marriages where sin is so entrenched, or harm so severe, that serious boundaries and outside help are necessary. Naming that reality is not a failure of selflessness. It can be an act of love.
But in many everyday marriages, the more common danger is not severe oppression but a slow drift into mutual self‑protection: two people standing back, arms crossed, each insisting, “You move first. You apologize first. You make it right first.”
Bonhoeffer’s counsel presses in exactly there: if you both wait to insist on what the other owes, the marriage empties of joy. If instead you both begin with the forgiveness you yourselves have received, you create space for something else to grow: humility, patience, and the kind of love that mirrors Christ’s.
Bringing It Home: Founding Your Marriage on Christ
So how do we bring all this back to the actual, ordinary life of a marriage?
Bonhoeffer’s sentence gives us a simple, daily liturgy:
- “Take one another as you are.” Receive your spouse not as a problem to fix, but as a person to love, with real sins and real beauty, just as Christ has received you.
- “Don’t insist on your rights.” Lay down the reflex to demand repayment for every hurt or to weaponize the language of what you are owed.
- “Forgive each other every day from the bottom of your hearts.” Make forgiveness a daily practice, not a rare event reserved for catastrophic offenses.
In doing this, you are not despising liberty. You are, in fact, honoring it as Christ did: using your freedom not to defend yourself at all costs, but to give yourself away in love.
Christ did not cling to His status, His comfort, or His rights. He gave them up to win a bride. When you, in your own small way, choose not to insist on your rights in your marriage—when you choose confession over blame, forgiveness over score‑keeping, humility over self‑protection—you are participating in that same story.
You are founding your marriage, not on a fragile balance of competing claims, but on the solid ground of Christ’s self‑giving love.
And that is the only ground strong enough to sustain a lifetime of two sinners living together in the forgiveness of their sins.
Comments